In A Whisper in the Dark, we are primarily introduced to the point of view of Sybil. We are led to believe everything that she says because she is our only source of information, since she is the only one that we can rely on as a narrator. Throughout the story, her character unfolds and we learn more and more about who she really is, and even though we start mistrusting her views a little we still have to rely on what she sees and thinks.
Since Sybil is the narrator once the concepts of insanity start playing in, we as the readers have no clue what to think because she doesn't even know what is going on herself. This is shown when she finds herself in the insane asylum and says, "Where am I, and am I here against my will?" (231). In a sense, the readers had a clue of what was going to possibly happen to Sybil before she did like when she wakes up from unconsciousness from her fall and starts asking questions and everybody is very suspiciously covert. As Sybil keeps on asking questions, her Uncle and Dr. Karnac have their own conversation going on and Dr. Karnac says, "If it continues, you are perfectly justified in doing so." (228). As I read that part, the first thing that came to my mind was that her Uncle was planning on doing something to her like sending her to some other place so she would not disturb his plans of acquiring her wealth. Even though instances like this give us clues as to what is possibly happening, we still have a stronghold on Sybil because what is happening to her is also very important. However, as our image of Sybil is altered, we start seeing the text as more mysterious and we start paying more attention to the actions of the other characters as well.
Throughout the whole story, Sybil is this outspoken, scheming character and as mentioned before in class, she is very much like Capitola. One main similarity is that both Capitola and Sybil did not grow up with mothers. Not growing up with mothers might have a big part in why Sybil is the way she is. Nevertheless, Sybil is "lady like" as shown when she meets Guy for the first time and she says, "Then I rose prepared to give him the coldest greeting, yet I did not." (215). Sybil is rebellious and flirtatious, but she still thinks about being polite especially to the man she finds attractive. I think if Sybil had been raised by her mother, she would be a lot more modest with her flirtations and she would not be as calculating as she originally is with her uncle and Guy. She would probably be more like Ellen from The Wide, Wide World and be less vain and more caring of others. Sybil drastically changes when she enters the asylum, and changes even more when she realizes her mother was the person that drove her crazy at night. This is shown when she reunites with Guy, and she is not trying to be conniving or flirtatious anymore but instead says, "when each saw each other by the light of this strange and sad experience--Guy poor, again, I free, the old bond still existing, the barrier of misunderstanding gone--- it was easy to see our way, easy to submit, to forgive, to forget, and begin anew the life these clouds had darkened for a time." (241).
I believe Sybil's change not only comes from being in the asylum, but also realizing that her mother was still alive and being affected by her mother's tragic situation made much of a difference. Sybil's relationship with her mother is completely the opposite from what we have seen in the past stories, yet she somehow still gains something from her mother, which is what the 19th century society and fiction advocated; mothers were supposed to be role models and they were supposed to teach their little girls how to be ladies. Sybil's mother saved her by warning her, but also finally made Sybil turn into a respectable, mature young lady.
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Uncle Tom's Cabin
One main theme I noticed in the past stories we have read is that children are almost represented as this idea of the "blank slate" from the philosophy of John Locke. In The Lamplighter for instance, Gerty was seen as a good, kind child for the most part except when her temper kicked in but we have this idea that she can be helped and eventually mended into an ideal young woman that will go by the standards of society. This idea also supports the theme about how children are associated with hope and potential. In Uncle Tom's Cabin, we notice the complete opposite idea about children. It is obvious that children are seen as a burden and a bother that will only complicate things, especially for slave traders like Haley.
Haley even mentions how he doesn't see how slave women are so attached to their children when all children do is bring them misery. He says, "I never could n't see into it; youn uns is heaps of trouble to 'em; one would think, now; they'd be glad to be clear on 'em; but they arn't." (259). In the world of slavery, children are not this idea of hope and potential, but rather bring complications, are not very useful, and slave children are certainly not helped by any strangers as with Ellen and Gerty in The Wide, Wide World and The Lamplighter. The only people that seem to value children in Uncle Tom's Cabin are those that are related to the child with the most important relative being the mother. Eliza even emphasizes how important her child is to her when she says, " I have lost two, one after another,-left 'em buried there when I came away; and I had only this one left. I never slept a night without him; he was all I had. He was my comfort and pride, day and night; and ma'am they were going to take him away from me,-sell him,-sell him down south, ma'am, to go all alone,-a baby that had never been away from his mother in his life!" (280). There is also the instance when the slave at the end of chapter 12 commits suicide when Haley sells her baby because that is all she probably had left as a purpose to keep going with her life.
In this instance, we see how cruel slavery was to children and especially their mothers. It is not the same situation as in the past stories where children end up being cared for and grow up to be fine representations of society because slave children did not have that chance. If a slave child grew up with their parent it was by a miracle because children were being traded and sold left and right along with their parents. Also, as Haley saw it, many slave owners saw children as a burden and something that would get in the way of succeessfully trading and selling slaves so it was also a miracle if a slave child grew up to be an exemplary adult because very few people wanted to deal with them.
Haley even mentions how he doesn't see how slave women are so attached to their children when all children do is bring them misery. He says, "I never could n't see into it; youn uns is heaps of trouble to 'em; one would think, now; they'd be glad to be clear on 'em; but they arn't." (259). In the world of slavery, children are not this idea of hope and potential, but rather bring complications, are not very useful, and slave children are certainly not helped by any strangers as with Ellen and Gerty in The Wide, Wide World and The Lamplighter. The only people that seem to value children in Uncle Tom's Cabin are those that are related to the child with the most important relative being the mother. Eliza even emphasizes how important her child is to her when she says, " I have lost two, one after another,-left 'em buried there when I came away; and I had only this one left. I never slept a night without him; he was all I had. He was my comfort and pride, day and night; and ma'am they were going to take him away from me,-sell him,-sell him down south, ma'am, to go all alone,-a baby that had never been away from his mother in his life!" (280). There is also the instance when the slave at the end of chapter 12 commits suicide when Haley sells her baby because that is all she probably had left as a purpose to keep going with her life.
In this instance, we see how cruel slavery was to children and especially their mothers. It is not the same situation as in the past stories where children end up being cared for and grow up to be fine representations of society because slave children did not have that chance. If a slave child grew up with their parent it was by a miracle because children were being traded and sold left and right along with their parents. Also, as Haley saw it, many slave owners saw children as a burden and something that would get in the way of succeessfully trading and selling slaves so it was also a miracle if a slave child grew up to be an exemplary adult because very few people wanted to deal with them.
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
The Hidden Hand
One interesting theme I encountered in The Hidden Hand was the contrast between older men and the younger men. There seems to be a drastic change in the way that older people are supposed to behave compared to the younger people.There seems to be more composure in the "adults" than the "children."
An obvious example of this theme is how Major Ira Warfield is described as "arrogant, domineering, and violent" (151), yet we see that he has this tender nature to him that he only shows in certain occassions. We see this kindness when despite his temper as he tells Wool to let in the stranger knocking in the middle of the night when he says, "Do you think I am going to turn a deaf ear to a stranger that comes to my house for shelter on such a night as this? Go and answer the bell directly." (153). Old Hurricane's kind heart also shows when he leaves during the middle of the night to go see the midwife that is dying and he listens to her whole story.(156) What really shows this man's true nature is when he goes to rescue Capitola and he sighs and laments the life that she has led up until then.
From the beginning, the reader is meant to believe that Major Ira is a selfish, bitter old man that doesn't want anything but his luxuries but we soon learn that he is far from that in reality. All through the beginning, Old Hurricane shows his kindness and sensitivity in very subtle ways because back in the 19th century and even somewhat today men were not supposed to be emotional or show any kind of strong feelings openly as we also see with Ellen's father in The Wide, Wide World. Despite this, there is one instance when Old Hurricane lets his emotions be seen, and this is when he finds out that the widow Herbert Greyson talked about is really his estranged wife, Marah. (203). Old Hurricane gets really angry when he realizes who Herbert Greyson is talking about, but then a sadness fills him as he "dropped his shaggy head and face into his hands and remained trembling from head to foot, while the convulsive heaving of his chest and the rising and falling of his huge shoulders betrayed that his heart was bursting with such suppressed sobs as only can be forced from manhood by the fiercest anguish." (204). This also shows that the only thing that would make a man cry is terrible anguish almost as if that is the only time a man is allowed to display his sadness. Even then Old Hurricane composes himself because Herbert points out how much "emotion" he is showing, so Old Hurricane is described as "getting up and shaking himself free of all weaknesses." (204). The irony in this is that Herbert Grayson acts very compassionately and even "pressed that rugged and hairy old hand to his lips" (204) meaning Old Hurrricane, and there seems to be nothing wrong with that.
There is a big contrast in the way that Traverse and Herbert are allowed to act compared to Old Hurricane and Marah Rocke. Even with Marah Rocke, since she is a woman her crying is not such a big deal. Yet, she still tries to hide the crying from Traverse "as she had managed to dismiss her boy with a smile, but that was the last effort of nature; as soon as he was gone she found herself alone, tear after tear welled up in her eyes and rolled down her pale cheeks" (209), which shows that adults were expected to be composed around their children whether male adult or female adult. Herbert and Traverse themselves are as emotional and compassionate as a man can be during that century and there is nothing that stops them from being that way. Traverse's emotions come to light when he says to Marah, "Mother, I love you more than son ever loved his mother, or suitor his sweetheart, or husband his wife! Oh! is my love nothing mother?" (208).This instance is extremely sensitive for a grown man but suitable for a child, yet Traverse is almost a full grown man. There is a strangeness in the way that the younger men display their emotions despite the way that Old Hurricane feels the need to hold back on his emotions and even reprimands himself for becoming too sensitive at times. This compassionate nature in men also comes up in Willie in The Lamplighter, and nothing seems out of place either when that happens maybe because he is also a younger man. It all seems as if children were the only ones allowed to show their emotions and adults were expected to hide them as much as possible because it was not okay for the adults to be vulnerable.
An obvious example of this theme is how Major Ira Warfield is described as "arrogant, domineering, and violent" (151), yet we see that he has this tender nature to him that he only shows in certain occassions. We see this kindness when despite his temper as he tells Wool to let in the stranger knocking in the middle of the night when he says, "Do you think I am going to turn a deaf ear to a stranger that comes to my house for shelter on such a night as this? Go and answer the bell directly." (153). Old Hurricane's kind heart also shows when he leaves during the middle of the night to go see the midwife that is dying and he listens to her whole story.(156) What really shows this man's true nature is when he goes to rescue Capitola and he sighs and laments the life that she has led up until then.
From the beginning, the reader is meant to believe that Major Ira is a selfish, bitter old man that doesn't want anything but his luxuries but we soon learn that he is far from that in reality. All through the beginning, Old Hurricane shows his kindness and sensitivity in very subtle ways because back in the 19th century and even somewhat today men were not supposed to be emotional or show any kind of strong feelings openly as we also see with Ellen's father in The Wide, Wide World. Despite this, there is one instance when Old Hurricane lets his emotions be seen, and this is when he finds out that the widow Herbert Greyson talked about is really his estranged wife, Marah. (203). Old Hurricane gets really angry when he realizes who Herbert Greyson is talking about, but then a sadness fills him as he "dropped his shaggy head and face into his hands and remained trembling from head to foot, while the convulsive heaving of his chest and the rising and falling of his huge shoulders betrayed that his heart was bursting with such suppressed sobs as only can be forced from manhood by the fiercest anguish." (204). This also shows that the only thing that would make a man cry is terrible anguish almost as if that is the only time a man is allowed to display his sadness. Even then Old Hurricane composes himself because Herbert points out how much "emotion" he is showing, so Old Hurricane is described as "getting up and shaking himself free of all weaknesses." (204). The irony in this is that Herbert Grayson acts very compassionately and even "pressed that rugged and hairy old hand to his lips" (204) meaning Old Hurrricane, and there seems to be nothing wrong with that.
There is a big contrast in the way that Traverse and Herbert are allowed to act compared to Old Hurricane and Marah Rocke. Even with Marah Rocke, since she is a woman her crying is not such a big deal. Yet, she still tries to hide the crying from Traverse "as she had managed to dismiss her boy with a smile, but that was the last effort of nature; as soon as he was gone she found herself alone, tear after tear welled up in her eyes and rolled down her pale cheeks" (209), which shows that adults were expected to be composed around their children whether male adult or female adult. Herbert and Traverse themselves are as emotional and compassionate as a man can be during that century and there is nothing that stops them from being that way. Traverse's emotions come to light when he says to Marah, "Mother, I love you more than son ever loved his mother, or suitor his sweetheart, or husband his wife! Oh! is my love nothing mother?" (208).This instance is extremely sensitive for a grown man but suitable for a child, yet Traverse is almost a full grown man. There is a strangeness in the way that the younger men display their emotions despite the way that Old Hurricane feels the need to hold back on his emotions and even reprimands himself for becoming too sensitive at times. This compassionate nature in men also comes up in Willie in The Lamplighter, and nothing seems out of place either when that happens maybe because he is also a younger man. It all seems as if children were the only ones allowed to show their emotions and adults were expected to hide them as much as possible because it was not okay for the adults to be vulnerable.
Thursday, February 4, 2010
The Lamplighter
Comparing how girls are expected to behave today and in the 19th century, I believe some things have changed but at the same time some principles are still in effect.
In the beginning of The Lamplighter, Gerty is portrayed as this rude, ugly child and only her eyes are of interest as shown when the author says, "Had anyone felt any interest in her (which nobody did), had she had a mother (which alas! she had not), those friendly and partial eyes would perhaps found something in her to praise." (80). In essence, Gerty is not a rude child but in fact she is a very passionate and loving child who only cares for others especially those she loves.This also shows that ugliness was associated with being a bad person, and beauty was associated with wealth and good manners. In today's world this is still seen in some aspects but not as emphasized as in the 19th century. Miss Emily and Willie notice what a great little person Gerty is and they understand why others see her as a bad child. When Gerty tells Willie about when she used to live with Nan Grant "he could not help smiling at her childish wrath, nor could he resist sympathizing with her in a degree, and almost wishing he could have a brush with Nan himself...But he had been well brought up by his gentle mother, was conscious that Gerty was exhibiting a very hot temper, and began to understand what made everybody think her so bad." (118). In today's world, little girls are still expected to be have well and not have tantrums. Gerty would probably still be criticized for having the anger tantrums she got when she spoke about Nan Grant. Although more people would sympathize with her, Gerty would still be seen as an angry and unruly child. Granted, today there is more leniency in raising children and people let their children have tanrums to a certain extent but there is still a certain way to be that children must follow.
On Amy Pohler's TV show, it is even stated that balance is important in the 8-year old's life and the little girl even says that one must not quit but instead try your best and try harder. In our society, this thought is pushed and pushed onto us as we grow up and we are afraid to quit or give up on anything because in our eyes that equals failure. Gerty is challenged with this belief when she meets Emily and later on expresses that she hates the girls at school and Nan Grant. Emily tells Gerty that it's bad to hate people and tells Gerty that if she wishes "to be good and be forgiven", she must "forgive others." (149). Gerty then asks "Will he [God] love me, and let me some time go to heaven?" and Emily says. " Yes if you try to be good, and Love everybody." This is when Gerty is challenged with trying or not and says, "I can't do it-so I s'pose I can't go." (149). Gerty is so set on trying to be good and trying to please Miss Emily that she wants to have faith in God and she wants to be able to go to heaven, but her anger confuses her and she does not know how she can get rid of the anger she feels towards the people that have done her harm.
One thing I noticed that is different today than it was in the 19th century is the idea of being oneself and not trying to be like anybody else. Anna, the girl on Amy Pohler's TV show emphasized how a person shouldn't try to be like anybody else but his or herself. This idea kind of contradicts how children have been raised all these years. Children are raised in a way that they always have a role model to look up to and they are trying to be like. Whether a child has a role model in his or her home or not, it does not matter because they will find that role model inside or outside the home because it is nature to emulate somebody. The only difference is that today, individualism is more emphasized that it was in the 19th century. Gerty has several role models in her home from True Flint, Mrs. Sullivan, Miss Emily, and even Willie.In the 19th century, little girls were expected to grow up and be just like their mothers, and to follow the norms that everybody else did. This is shown when True brings up Emily's idea of Gerty going to school. "Gerty herself was very much disgusted with the idea, but it met with Willie's warm approbation; and when Gerty learned that Miss Graham also wished it, she consented, though rather reluctantly, to begin next week, and try how she liked it." (145). Gerty would probably not have agreed to go to school if she hadn't seen that Willie agreed with it or that Miss Emily wanted her to do it. This supports how much children were expected to do what adults wanted from them, and there wasn't really any individualism back then.
If Gerty would have been on Amy Poheler's TV show, I don't think balance would have been emphasized as much as it was with the other girl. Gerty would have probably had a fit of rage because Nan Grant would have been brought up. Even in today's standards, Gerty would have been seen as a weird, rude child for having an anger tantrum because children are supposed to be taught to be polite and nice around other people. Gerty can be nice and loving around others because we see that in The Lamplighter, but the one thing most people see all the time are the negative aspects of a person and with Gerty it's her temper. Gerty has a lot of individualism and that is the only thing that I think would have been agreeable on Amy Pohler's TV show.
In the beginning of The Lamplighter, Gerty is portrayed as this rude, ugly child and only her eyes are of interest as shown when the author says, "Had anyone felt any interest in her (which nobody did), had she had a mother (which alas! she had not), those friendly and partial eyes would perhaps found something in her to praise." (80). In essence, Gerty is not a rude child but in fact she is a very passionate and loving child who only cares for others especially those she loves.This also shows that ugliness was associated with being a bad person, and beauty was associated with wealth and good manners. In today's world this is still seen in some aspects but not as emphasized as in the 19th century. Miss Emily and Willie notice what a great little person Gerty is and they understand why others see her as a bad child. When Gerty tells Willie about when she used to live with Nan Grant "he could not help smiling at her childish wrath, nor could he resist sympathizing with her in a degree, and almost wishing he could have a brush with Nan himself...But he had been well brought up by his gentle mother, was conscious that Gerty was exhibiting a very hot temper, and began to understand what made everybody think her so bad." (118). In today's world, little girls are still expected to be have well and not have tantrums. Gerty would probably still be criticized for having the anger tantrums she got when she spoke about Nan Grant. Although more people would sympathize with her, Gerty would still be seen as an angry and unruly child. Granted, today there is more leniency in raising children and people let their children have tanrums to a certain extent but there is still a certain way to be that children must follow.
On Amy Pohler's TV show, it is even stated that balance is important in the 8-year old's life and the little girl even says that one must not quit but instead try your best and try harder. In our society, this thought is pushed and pushed onto us as we grow up and we are afraid to quit or give up on anything because in our eyes that equals failure. Gerty is challenged with this belief when she meets Emily and later on expresses that she hates the girls at school and Nan Grant. Emily tells Gerty that it's bad to hate people and tells Gerty that if she wishes "to be good and be forgiven", she must "forgive others." (149). Gerty then asks "Will he [God] love me, and let me some time go to heaven?" and Emily says. " Yes if you try to be good, and Love everybody." This is when Gerty is challenged with trying or not and says, "I can't do it-so I s'pose I can't go." (149). Gerty is so set on trying to be good and trying to please Miss Emily that she wants to have faith in God and she wants to be able to go to heaven, but her anger confuses her and she does not know how she can get rid of the anger she feels towards the people that have done her harm.
One thing I noticed that is different today than it was in the 19th century is the idea of being oneself and not trying to be like anybody else. Anna, the girl on Amy Pohler's TV show emphasized how a person shouldn't try to be like anybody else but his or herself. This idea kind of contradicts how children have been raised all these years. Children are raised in a way that they always have a role model to look up to and they are trying to be like. Whether a child has a role model in his or her home or not, it does not matter because they will find that role model inside or outside the home because it is nature to emulate somebody. The only difference is that today, individualism is more emphasized that it was in the 19th century. Gerty has several role models in her home from True Flint, Mrs. Sullivan, Miss Emily, and even Willie.In the 19th century, little girls were expected to grow up and be just like their mothers, and to follow the norms that everybody else did. This is shown when True brings up Emily's idea of Gerty going to school. "Gerty herself was very much disgusted with the idea, but it met with Willie's warm approbation; and when Gerty learned that Miss Graham also wished it, she consented, though rather reluctantly, to begin next week, and try how she liked it." (145). Gerty would probably not have agreed to go to school if she hadn't seen that Willie agreed with it or that Miss Emily wanted her to do it. This supports how much children were expected to do what adults wanted from them, and there wasn't really any individualism back then.
If Gerty would have been on Amy Poheler's TV show, I don't think balance would have been emphasized as much as it was with the other girl. Gerty would have probably had a fit of rage because Nan Grant would have been brought up. Even in today's standards, Gerty would have been seen as a weird, rude child for having an anger tantrum because children are supposed to be taught to be polite and nice around other people. Gerty can be nice and loving around others because we see that in The Lamplighter, but the one thing most people see all the time are the negative aspects of a person and with Gerty it's her temper. Gerty has a lot of individualism and that is the only thing that I think would have been agreeable on Amy Pohler's TV show.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)